Showing posts with label Naturalism. Show all posts
Showing posts with label Naturalism. Show all posts

Video: Proof of Christianity: Challenging Skeptics

Tuesday, April 22, 2008 | Labels: , , , | |

VenomFangX (Shawn) is one of the many popular young individuals on YouTube who openly discusses criticisms and skepticisms of God. In this particular video, he provides strong logical proof of Christianity by challenging skeptics to fully understand their position when they say the prophecies and historical contexts of the Bible are a man-made fantasy.

(Shawn 0:01) "Hey there, today's video is basically going to be a case for Christianity. I am going to present an argument to you that I believe is so irrefutable that you will not be able to call yourself a rational thinking person and not convert to Christianity."

(Shawn 0:15) "Now many people actually already believe in God they just don't know which religion to turn to in order to find the true and living God. Well, I am here to say to you God does not want a religion, he wants a relationship. It was a religion that crucified Jesus and I believe Jesus is God. We're not going to get there yet.

(Shawn 0:32) "The Bible is actually the most unique book in all of antiquity in fact in the whole history of mankind. It is not actually one book written by one ambiguous guy that we know nothing about, unlike the Koran and other supposed "Holy books". The Bible is a compilation of many books, around 66 books written over a period of many thousands of years. These books within the Bible are actually written by over forty different authors who lived lifetimes apart and often in countries apart."

(Shawn 1:00) "There's no way they could have corresponded with each other being so far apart in both geography and just in time. These various authors progressively revealed a God who, going by the name of Yahweh or "I Am" in English. This God revealed the plan of redemption for mankind going right back to the book of Genesis, the first book in the Bible, all the way to Malachi."

(Shawn 1:24) "Now, if you don't believe God is big enough to use man as a tool in his hand to write a book to get it to you then you need a bigger God. Basically, if I was to write a letter in a red pen, did I write the letter or did the red pen? You wouldn't say the red pen wrote it, you'd say I wrote it, likewise God wrote the Bible over many thousands of years using men as his instrument in so doing.

(Shawn 1:43) "So, what can we find within the text to say that this is not just of a human origin, that it is clearly of supernatural origin. Let's talk about that. Now I know that I am speaking as if I have already proven the existence of God to you, and... I have other videos about proving the existence of God and you can consult those if you want too, but lets talk about the Bible and how it itself is proof of God.

(Shawn 2:08) "Now, lets just go with the hypothetical that God is real and he wants us to worship him and know him. Just looking at the very texts that we use today [that] are all around the world for the various Gods we have such as Hinduism, Buddhism, the Koran for Islam, the Bible for the Christians and the Torah for the Jews. There are other lesser scriptures but it seems to me if God is really concerned with human affairs, then he would want us all to have his word. The Bible is not only the most printed book in the history of mankind, it is also the one book that has been translated into the most languages. So just by the sheer numbers and the sheer amount of people that have the Bible in their hands it seems God has been using that book uniquely more than any other book. That alone should point you in the Direction, if there is a God, that's an if, although I've proved it in other videos but if there is a book that God is circulating for us to know his will for us it seems the Bible is the one."

(Shawn 3:04) "Now lets talk about the contents of the Bible and why we would be able to open it up and say "Hmm, there's no way a man could have wrote that." And that is exactly what we would expect if God indeed wrote that book right? And, of course, I have already said it's not just one book, it's many books. God wouldn't exactly make us just rely on what one person said and I'm not even asking you to rely on what I said, pick up the Bible and look for it yourself I am not making up stuff. The greatest miracle and the greatest proof in the Bible's favor is actually Jesus Christ himself and the spreading of the gospel message. Yes the Bible is reaching every nation in the world, and the amazing thing is the prophecies given by the old prophets of the Torah of Israel, they all said the messiah to come would bring the entire world into the knowledge of the God of Israel.

(Shawn 3:51) "Jesus is no doubt the single vessel in which this has become a reality, now there is a timeline given by the prophets before Jesus was born and if you don't believe these texts were written before Jesus was born look to the discovery of the dead sea scrolls, they were discovered in 1948 or 1947, and they have all of the Old Testament books in them. These old testament books contain the prophecies of the messiah to come and they were written before Jesus came. They said the messiah would come, die and then the temple would be destroyed. This messiah had to bring the whole world into the knowledge of Israel before his death and before the destruction of the second temple in 70 A.D. which happened right after Jesus died.

(Shawn 4:31) "So either Jesus is the messiah or there is none and every evidence in all reality points to the fact that he is because look at the whole world, it knows now the God of Israel. All the gentiles of the world now worship the God of Israel, who was simply the God of the Israelites until Jesus was known. So, imagine then, I mean if you're being completely skeptical here and your saying you still don't believe it. Basically here is what you believe, you believe that a book was written about a fictitious God who gave a timeline of when someone would come along, born in Bethlehem, born of a virgin, give great miracles, die, be resurrected from the dead, people actually believe in him, spread the message to the whole world. You believe that was to happen, given the exact timeline that you've given, because you believe this was fictionally written by some fallible men. So this fictional God that just someone made up, came up with all that stuff and then it came to pass.

(Shawn 5:20) "I mean, what are the odds of that? Why don't you try it? Go ahead and try it. Write about some fictional messiah, and then some people actually have to meet him, believe in him, then spread the message to the whole world and the whole world has to believe it and then on top of that, you have to have people like me who are of Jewish background come to the realization and recognition of this messiah who was then foretold in your scriptures above all else when I actually pray to this God he actually answers me. So uhh.. yeah you've got a heavy task at hand.

(Shawn 5:47) "What's even more incredible than that simply ludicrous hypothetical that the Bible could have been just made up and happened to fulfill all the prophecies that it made about itself. If you look at Isaiah 49 it talks about the redeemer of Israel coming and being a light to the Gentiles and being abhorred by the nation of Israel. So, tell me, what are the chances of this? You have this holy text, which the Israelites, which are the Jews, they believe... they believe every word of it. Within their own text it says that they would abhor the redeemer to come and that the whole Gentile world would receive the messiah, the redeemer, and then at the same time they would still continue to reject him even though he has fulfilled their own prophecies. Do you see how incredible that is?

(Shawn 6:30) "And then on top of that you have the Muslims which are a fulfillment of prophecy as well. For you see, Jesus said, and all throughout scripture we see, that the anti-Christ, who is anyone who rejects that Jesus is the messiah and the son of God, would come in to seed the whole world. We all know that the Muslims, or Islam is a very progressive religion. It is spreading. Jesus said that the deception of the anti-Christ would be over the whole world and I have said in an earlier video that Muslims are very proud that their religion is growing so fast and it just is a fulfillment of what Jesus said that the anti-Christ would come, and that the deception would be over the whole world.

(Shawn 7:05) "Now, lets do another hypothetical. What are the chances of a fictional religion coming up with a messiah figure who would come, be foretold to be rejected by the very believers of the messiah, then be accepted by the whole world and then, right after that, a anti-Christ or an anti-Messiah like figure would come and then have the whole world reject this messiah. I mean, it's just layer upon layer upon layer and all of them are coming to pass. Now if you believe that's just a blind chance or coincidence, umm, that's ridiculous."

(Shawn 7:38) "So, lets just do a recap of everything we talked about. In fact were going to do a little bit of history of the Bible. Let's start back from the very beginning when God revealed himself. So God, Yahweh, "I Am" revealed himself to Moses... he gave his ten commandments and started giving prophecies about the redeemer to come. So, all throughout scripture we can look at Isaiah, who spoke I think more than any other of the prophets of the messiah to come.

(Shawn 8:05) "If you look at Isaiah 7:14 it talks about the virgin birth. If you look at Isaiah 9:6 it talks about how this child would be called God. If you go to Isaiah 53 it talks about how the messiah would suffer and die for our sins. If you look at Isaiah 49 it talks about how this redeemer would come and be rejected and abhorred by the nation but be a light to the Gentiles.

(Shawn 8:23) "So, here we have this, I'm looking at it from an atheistic point of view, I'm trying to, you know, help you guys out here. Basically you believe that these Israelites made up their religion and... made up this savior figure who then, did come, or you say they made [him] up as well, this Jesus of Nazareth who is documented in history but lets say, for the sake of argument that he is made up. Okay so, he comes in fiction. So people start writing stories about this messiah who then fulfilled prophecies from an Atheist point of view.

(Shawn 8:52) "So, people then accept it and say "Yeah, okay, he fulfilled scriptures" and then there is the people of the old faith who then reject this messiah according to prophecy, or according to what their fictional story said. ...Then, this new fictional story about Jesus says within it's scripture that then there would come a point where someone else would come and then have all of the world reject this new belief. So then Islam comes around, and you have them fulfilling exactly what these other fictional writers are saying about the anti-Christ.

(Shawn 9:23) "So, it seems to me that... this is not just a coincidence after coincidence after coincidence. This is simply the greatest hoax or the greatest... what's the word I am looking for... Basically I don't even think there is a word for it, it's so astronomically impossible that I simply cannot believe that ... there's any other explanation than the Bible is true. There's just nothing, I mean, come on, let's be serious.

(Shawn 9:49) "How can you possibly believe that all of that, I mean, and that's just scratching the surface. The Bible's a real thick book and every prophecy in it has come true except the ones that are about the last days which are coming true now. So, if you still want to maintain... a Naturalistic world-view and believe the Bible is just written by man you're giving a lot for men, to men, for coming up with such an ingenious story and having it all fulfilled. So, if you're still an Atheist or you're still completely skeptical check out my other videos and just really ask yourself, how can everything I just mentioned be possible if there is no God if what is being written is simply fictional. It transcends any fictional writing in the history of mankind."

This video has been typed out so others can view Shawn's argument in the written form, allowing for further research into the subject.

Be sure to visit Shawn's other works at: http://www.youtube.com/user/VenomFangX

Craig Chamberlin





Related Articles:
3 Reasons Christians Don't Need Scientific "Proof" of God
Science Assumes the Natural, Therefore Concludes the Natural
Analyzing: Christian Bill O'Reilly vs Atheist Richard Dawkins
Naturalists Use Faith to Argue Against God and Creationism
Jesus Christ's Sacrifice as the Ultimate Act of Love

3 Reasons Christians Don't Need Scientific "Proof" of God

Friday, April 4, 2008 | Labels: , , , , | |

Reason #1: Historical Evidences Strongly Verify The Existence, The Teachings and the Miracles Performed by Jesus

This argument was illustrated well by Josh McDowell:

"Many people try to put off personal commitment to Christ by voicing the assumption that if you cannot prove something scientifically, it is not true or worthy of acceptance. Since one cannot prove scientifically the Deity of Jesus or the resurrection, the twentieth-century individual should know better than to accept Christ as savior or to believe in the resurrection...

There is a problem of proving about a person or event in history. We need to understand the difference between scientific proof and what I call legal-historical proof...

Scientific proof is based on showing something is a fact by repeating the event in the presence of the person questioning the fact. There is a controlled environment where observations can be made, data drawn, and hypotheses empirically verified...

Now if the scientific method was the only method of proving something, you couldn't prove that you went to your first hour class this morning or that you had lunch today. There's no way you can repeat those events in a controlled situation....

...legal-historical proof [is when]... a verdict is reached on the basis of the weight of evidence... it depends upon three types of testimony: oral testimony, written testimony, and exhibits... Using the legal method of what happened, you could pretty well prove beyond a reasonable doubt that you were in class this morning: your friends saw you, you have your notes, the professor remembers you.

- Josh McDowell, More Than a Carpenter, 1977

To avoid length summarizing the following chapter McDowell illustrates how the New Testament "has more manuscript authority than any piece of literature from antiquity... one can conclude that an authentic New Testament text has been established..."

He also points out a comment from a trained individual of historical investigation named Will Durant who stated, "...that a few simple men should in one generation have invented so powerful and appealing a personality, so lofty an ethic, and so inspiring a vision of human brotherhood, would be a miracle far more incredible than any recorded in the Gospels. After two centuries of Higher Criticism the outlines of the life, character and teachings of Christ remain reasonably clear, and constitute fascinating feature in the history of Western Man."

As a third illustration of verifiability, he quotes Dr. Clark H. Pinnock, a professor of systematic theology at Regent College who states, "There exists no document from the ancient world witnessed by so excellent a set of textual and historical testimonies, and offering so superb an array of historical data on which an intelligent decision may be made. An honest [person] cannot dismiss a source of this kind. Skepticism regarding the historical credentials of Christianity is based upon an irrational [i.e., antisupernatural] bias."

This is only a portion of his illustrations, his discussion regarding these conclusions is extensive and I would recommend reading them before discrediting them.

An Online Recommended Reading of Historical New Testament Evidences: The Unrivaled Resurrection

Reason # 2: Christian's have been Personal Witnesses to the Transforming Power of Believing in Christ and his Teachings.

One needs to look no further than any born again Christian who transformed their lives from drug addiction, alcohol addiction, sex or lust addiction and experienced the saving power and grace of the Holy Spirit or the everyday Christian who has found happiness and joy. These transformations do not always occur overnight but many Christians can illustrate to you just when they became a Christian because a powerful transformation of the desires of their heart took place when they accepted Christ.

One should be careful not to dismiss this idea as a "spiritual high". The Christian often doesn't receive a wondrous feeling of euphoria but finds their mind being convicted things they ought and ought not be doing. The spirit gives an individual the ability to communicate and consult God on questions about life, troubles and their own personal vices.

One strongly recommended reading for any individual who does not fully understand how Christ can transform the heart of man ought to read a book entitled Impossible Joy where a man struggling with sex and lust addiction who was "religious" his whole life found out he never had a relationship with Christ and later in his life actually accepted Christ into his heart and brought him through one of the most incredible transformations and freedoms from his struggle.

Reason # 3: Every Semi-coherent Ethical Doctrine Attempted Apart from Christ Uses His Teachings.

It ought to be pointed out that when the majority of individuals are asked how individuals ought to behave their response on unethical behaviors lands near the ten commandments and illustrates it should be interpreted with the Golden Rule, "treat others the way you want to be treated" in mind. Brilliant as it is, Christ summarized all of his teachings with that commandment.

"Jesus replied, “‘You must love the Lord your God with all your heart, all your soul, and all your mind.’ This is the first and greatest commandment. A second is equally important: ‘Love your neighbor as yourself.’ The entire law and all the demands of the prophets are based on these two commandments.”"

- Matthew 22:37-40

Ironically, the first commandment can be conveniently ignored by other ethical doctrines. If you read deep into each and every attempt at ethics apart from God and other systems that attempt to establish laws and moral codes, you will find that each one tries to communicate how to "love your neighbor as you love yourself" without Christ's help.

Given that Christ established the foundation of all attempts at a godless ethic himself 2000 years ago, given his philosophical conception of an unthinkable, unimaginable system by which to consult and lean on God through the Holy Spirit, given the continued existence of one of the most incredible historically accurate testaments to his teachings on how to follow that ethic and given the witnessing that many people still are and continue to be miraculously transformed by Christ and his teachings - believing in him, and who this simple carpenter from Nazareth claimed to be is not too difficult of a leap to make without scientific "proof" of the existence of God.

Craig Chamberlin






Related Articles:

Science Assumes the Natural, Therefore Concludes the Natural

Wednesday, April 2, 2008 | Labels: , | |

The scientific method is a brilliant way to observe and theorize knowledge. It has existed for a very long time, but it has been discussed this week how that method can be hijacked to be used as something it was not originally intended. There are important considerations to point out relating to the scope of the scientific methods capabilities to observe, isolate and elaborate theories.

The methods used by science are limited to natural, observable, and sometimes re creatable tests. These tests are then evaluated time and time again to draw a consensus or a consistency to justify the probability that what it concludes is a credible theory. For example, the classic test of dropping an apple next to a bowling ball to find they hit the ground at the same time illustrates that objects are equally affected by gravitation. To verify the accuracy of this test it is done countless times and the results observed and recorded.

What would happen if the process of nature was violated? What if a supernatural event occurred? Would science be able to verify the event were actually supernatural?

It would be able to verify it is supernatural only under the terms that it violates the natural tests and by the law of non contradiction suggest one of two conclusions:

1) The event was indeed natural, but the methods of science are limited in explaining it.
2) The event violated strongly verified tests of the natural, and therefore was a supernatural event.

An event cannot be both natural and supernatural because by their very definitions they are contradicting points. Let us examine the possibility of an individual coming back from the dead days after their own death. This event would be considered supernatural only because science has collectively observed the impossibility of such an event occurring naturally. So it is supernatural because it contradicts a strongly verified test of the natural.

Science's scope, therefore, is not to analyze the possibility of the supernatural, but to attempt to give every explanation within its methods to prove an event occurred naturally - and if it cannot do so, then by the law of contradiction, conclude it was supernatural or that it is still natural yet science is too weak in that particular field to test how.

In a round-a-bout way we have come to an important bias in science. All events are assumed to be natural until every effort of science fails to give an acceptable explanation as to how it occurred naturally therefore rendering it supernatural. Does this not make perfect sense with the theory of the origins of man?

Abiogenesis, or the study of origin of life through the lens of the scientific method must first assume life came about naturally, and then create tests and theories based upon that assumption. For an individual from the outside to suggest "In the beginning, God..." violates the very rules of the scientific method. Science, therefore can only conclude that man originated from both probable chance and from mud, because before man there was only mud and if the causation of life must adhere to science it must be probable chance.

It is only when science fails to illustrate a coherent explanation to the probabilistic chances and provide the empirical evidences necessary to prove every theory of the origins of life will science finally admit a supernatural event must have occurred. Science has not yet reached this point in it's theories on abiogenesis. To argue against a scientist against scientific theories regarding the origins of life is to argue with a religious person regarding the origins of life. Both have their feet deeply rooted in their own tests of reality, and neither can admit to the other being correct without evidences necessary to make them stand out of each-others roots.

In other words, if one would like a evolution-scientist to accept creation they would first need to illustrate to the evolution-scientists that their tests have failed in huge respects... impossible for many really because their fallback lands on 'science is still limited, so that is why we have failed to provide the answers to the tests'.

If one would like a religious individual to accept evolutionary abiogenesis - they would need to illustrate the most solidified, blatantly obvious acceptable evidences of origins deriving from mud ranging from both creating intelligence from non-intelligence, better probabilistic chances that have been offered and answers to holes that tend to be poked (they are legitimate philosophical, logical and scientific holes in many many cases) by creationists in the evolution-scientists theories. The outcry from creationists aims more toward demanding stronger evidences before accepting abiogenesis as a verified scientific theory.

The important thing every individual should keep in mind is that science assumes the natural and is adamantly attempting to dis-theorize the supernatural. This assumption is what spawns theories such as evolutionary abiogenesis, it does not, however, give any credit to the possibility of a supernatural event occurring because to do so would be to violate science. So it makes perfect sense that science has only concluded the origins of life spawned from natural means because it is the only conclusion science can draw without being a complete and total failure in verifying the evidences presented by every scientific means possible. Concluding a supernatural event is basically admitting science has failed. One can see why scientists would be reluctant to make such a conclusion.

Craig Chamberlin



Philosophical Flaws of the Science God

Tuesday, April 1, 2008 | Labels: , , , | |

Naturalism is a philosophy that adheres to the scientific method as being the only test of reality. Philosophy often uses science to partially justify itself, but science's role was ultimately not to answer philosophical questions. The majority of individuals tend to decide on their philosophy and observe scientific evidences through the lens of their own philosophies.

It is important to first briefly differentiate between science and philosophy, many individuals are mistaken to believe that they are one in the same. Philosophy addresses a combination of four different realms of questions (wikipedia.org):

1. Ethics, what is right and wrong conduct.
2. Metaphysics, investigates principles transcending any particular science, what is the essential nature and being of the world.
3. Epistemology, what counts as genuine knowledge.
4. Logic, principles of reasoning.

Science is a subset used to examine and explain the following(wikipedia.org):

1. Observable occurrences.
2. Acquisition, correction and integration of knowledge.

As one can see, science on it's own deals only with epistemology and logic. When one uses science beyond these to explain metaphysics or ethics they transcend the role of science, this is where the naturalist tends to reach a dilemma. Metaphysics and science are not the same thing. Metaphysics transcends science to attempt to answer questions beyond science.

Where is Naturalism in the Purpose of Life?

Science on it's own cannot answer the question, so the naturalist tends to argue one of two things, either the question is unimportant or irrelevant (and if they do, then they face an utter disaster in the realm of metaphysics) or that life has no purpose.

When asked what man's purpose is, the naturalist can not give a coherent answer without stepping on the toes of another naturalist, and cannot justify their purpose to life without scientific evidences and science cannot transcend itself as metaphysics demands. Therefore, naturalists offer no answers to metaphysical questions because by their very nature, they argue metaphysical questions of origins and purpose to life are invalid and unnecessary questions. There is no purpose to life, because this purpose must be scientifically justified, which it cannot.

For the naturalist who is going to argue with this argument I ask this one question. What is the purpose of life, and how is your purpose to life scientifically justified as naturalism demands?

Where is Naturalism in the Hope amidst Despair?

We have already established that purposes and why's of the world through naturalism cannot be answered coherently, because to establish a coherent argument it must be scientifically justified. Next we move onto those who are in suffering and the suffering of the world. If an individual is dying of cancer the naturalist must have only one explanation to the individual and that is that they are unlucky and it's unfortunate that when one dies, that is the end of all things.

There can be no hope or purpose in pain, Christian philosophy often takes individuals who are suffering and use that suffering to bring about a wondrous transformation in an individuals life - and with few years left to live give them the wondrous knowledge of this life not being the end. This, in and of itself, makes the naturalist argue that when an individual is in unlivable circumstances by their standards that they would be better off dead than alive - it offers no transformation of hopeless pain to hope, which would only be expected to exist if a God existed.

For the naturalist who will argue this is a wonderful fairy tale and crutch for those who are in suffering, but at least we deal with reality I have one question. If God were to exist in reality, does it not make perfect sense that he would deliver the suffering from their despair amidst their suffering?

Where is Naturalism with Tolerance?

To avoid length this will be the last topic discussed. Naturalist who embrace the scientific method as the only test of reality are forced to adhere to an intolerant philosophy. You see when individuals embrace a philosophy that exacts that it is the only test of reality it must eventually come up with a framework of right and wrong that everyone should agree too. These ideas of right and wrong must be filtered through the tests of reality (or the scientific method in this case).

So when a naturalist argues that everyone should be tolerant of other's viewpoints they are either ill-informed of their own philosophy or lying. This is why the comment made that "We don't mind religion as long as they don't get their so called truths involved in government" is a truly naturalist statement. It filters through the lens of the scientific method what 'truth' is in regard to morality and ethics. There has yet to be an ethical framework that can be coherent through science and separated from an absolute. Yet, the naturalist is closer to adhering to an absolute than they might realize, to embrace science as the only test of reality is to embrace an absolute method to determine right and wrong. Just as embracing a Deity as a test of right and wrong. It does not mean right and wrong are simple black and white, but it means right and wrong must be filtered through an absolute test of reality.

For the naturalist who will accuse the religious of adhering to an intolerant philosophy I have one comment. Although Christianity in particular is an absolute, therefore making it "intolerant" to other viewpoints, its followers do not embrace (as naturalists often do) a relative morality. Naturalists attempt to argue in one hand every person can determine what is right and wrong but in the other they demand in the public forum that right and wrong be filtered through their philosophy. The naturalist often preaches tolerance when the philosophy itself is just as intolerant as the religious viewpoints. This is meant as a clarifying point.

Craig Chamberlin